Transmissible cancer, a tumour lineage that spreads as living cells between animals rather than arising fresh in each victim, has been confirmed in only three groups: dogs, Tasmanian devils, and several bivalves. A study published in Nature now adds a fourth: a melanoma circulating among brown bullhead catfish (Ameiurus nebulosus) in a lake straddling the Vermont–Quebec border. It is the first transmissible cancer identified in any fish, and the first found in a freshwater ecosystem.
The case opened in 2012, when anglers and biologists began reporting black lesions on bullhead pulled from Lake Memphremagog, a 32-mile body of water that also supplies drinking water to more than 175,000 people. Earlier surveys established that the spots were malignant melanomas and put prevalence between 23 and 37 percent of fish examined, an extraordinary rate for the species; by 2014 nearly one in three carried them. “That was surprising,” said Julie Dragon, a University of Vermont researcher and co-lead author. “We wanted to know how a bottom-dwelling fish was getting a cancer we associate with exposure to too much sunlight.” Suspicion initially fell on contamination, from Tropical Storm Irene’s 2011 flooding or the nearby Coventry landfill, but the lesions were spread evenly across the lake rather than clustered near either.
The genomic work pointed somewhere else entirely. Dragon’s team, with UVM fish biologist Mark Henderson and Vermont state biologist Peter Emerson, ran whole-genome sequencing on tumours alongside matched healthy tissue from the same animals. Both the nuclear and mitochondrial genomes of tumours from different fish proved more closely related to one another than to the hosts carrying them, and hundreds of thousands of genetic variants recurred across tumours while being absent from those hosts. In hundreds of human melanomas the team examined for comparison, nearly every mutation is unique to its patient; the catfish tumours showed the inverse. Screening turned up no virus or bacterium specifically tied to the tumours, which does not rule out a pathogen in the cancer’s origin but leaves the cancer cells themselves as the agent being transmitted.
How those cells move between fish is unresolved. The authors offer three routes: bullhead crowd into confined shallows to spawn, where contact could pass cells directly; tumour cells may survive briefly in water or sediment and enter a scaleless bottom-dweller through skin, gills, or mouth; or spawning hormones may dampen immunity enough for a graft to take. “It seems to only happen in larger fish that are of spawning age,” Henderson said. The team also measured elevated arsenic in tumour cells and a geographic correlation with naturally arsenic-rich ground, while stressing that the association does not establish cause. Nor is the lineage confined to Memphremagog: lesions have surfaced in waters across Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine, and New Brunswick, and Thoreau recorded “velvet-black” catfish on the Concord River in 1852.
Independent specialists call the central claim solid while marking what it leaves open. The genetic evidence for a common origin across individual tumours is “overwhelming,” said Adrián Báez-Ortega of the University of Cambridge, but the transmission route, the age and birthplace of the lineage, the way it slips past fish immune systems, and its long-term effect on populations all remain unsettled; the team is now sampling Massachusetts ponds for a source. Risk to people appears negligible, since cancer transmission between humans is exceedingly rare, though Henderson gave anglers a blunter rule: “I wouldn’t eat the ones with tumors.” Cambridge’s Elizabeth Murchison and others suspect the larger unknown is the count itself. Four documented transmissible cancers may say less about how rarely they arise than about how seldom anyone goes looking.
Discover more from TekCrispy
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



TekCrispy