Every surveillance network built for public safety is eventually tested by the people holding the keys, and the record of that test is usually thin. A Washington Post analysis published this week found that authorities have charged or accused at least 50 law enforcement officers of querying automated license plate readers for unauthorized reasons. In 26 of those cases, investigators and prosecutors said the officer was tracking a wife, a girlfriend, an ex, an ex’s new partner, or a woman he wanted to meet. Forty-six involved Flock Safety cameras.

The clearest case runs through Jefferson, Georgia. Marci Bakely spent months unable to explain how her former boyfriend always knew where she was, installing security cameras and having her car checked for trackers. Audit logs compiled by Have I Been Flocked, which reconstructs Flock query records from public records requests, showed roughly 600 searches of her plate and her teenage daughter’s. They were attributed to Michael Steffman, then police chief in nearby Braselton, who had already admitted by text that he was using the cameras to follow her. He was arrested in November on stalking and misuse charges and found dead at home in April, before trial.

Other cases ended in convictions. Former California deputy Alexander Vanny was sentenced to six years on ten counts including stalking and unauthorized data access. A Wisconsin officer allegedly searched to check whether an ex-girlfriend had visited an abortion clinic, and a Kansas police chief was fired after using plate data to find his ex. The scale is unusual for a private vendor: Flock says it runs more than 120,000 cameras across over 6,000 communities and records some 20 billion plate scans a month, an index of vehicle movement no single agency built and no single agency governs. That reach has already left cameras destroyed in several states and dozens of contracts canceled.

Chief executive Garrett Langley frames the problem as unfixable at the level of the user. “We’re not going to change humans, and humans make bad decisions,” he said. “What we can do is make sure that they know if you use this tool, you will be held accountable.” Flock rolled out an audit assistance feature in April that flags suspicious patterns, such as repeated queries on one vehicle or searches run off shift, and promised better filters after the Post’s findings. The feature is voluntary and enforcement stays with the buying department, the same split that shapes other vendor-built police search tools.

California is trying to move that responsibility into statute. Senate Bill 1013, from Sen. Sabrina Cervantes of Riverside, would cap retention at 30 days outside active investigations, require a case number for every search, bar contracts granting federal or out-of-state agencies default access, and direct the state Department of Justice to run random annual audits. It is pending before the Assembly Appropriations Committee. Newsom vetoed a similar Cervantes bill last year over cold cases and audit costs, and at least 39 police agencies and unions oppose this one. At least 230 California departments already run plate readers.

What none of this establishes is how often the misuse happens. Every documented case surfaced the same way, through an internal audit, a protective order or a records request filed long after the searches, so the count measures detection, not behavior, and no one has published the denominator. Courts have not settled whether searching billions of monthly scans requires a warrant, and Congress has not written a rule. Until one does, the line between a public safety tool and a national location database sits wherever the person logged in puts it.


Discover more from TekCrispy

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply